Leaving colorectal polyps in situ with endocytoscopy assisted by computer-aided diagnosis: a cost-effectiveness study.
Halvorsen N., Barua I., Kudo S-E., Gulati S., Misawa M., Mori K., Hayee B., Olabintan O., Nilsen JA., Frigstad SO., East JE., Rastogi A., Hassan C., Kalager M., Løberg M., Holme Ø., Haji A., Bretthauer M., Mori Y.
Computer-aided diagnosis (CADx) enables the distinction between neoplastic and non-neoplastic polyps during colonoscopy. We aimed to estimate the patient-level benefit and harm of CADx. We conducted a comparative analysis on data from the EndoBRAIN international clinical trial, evaluating the effect of optical diagnosis during colonoscopy with and without CADx. Three hypothetical scenarios were compared: "endoscopist-alone" and "CADx-assisted" leave-in-situ strategies (leaving non-neoplastic rectosigmoid polyps ≤ 5 mm), and "total removal" (removing all detected polyps). Primary outcomes included patient-level colonoscopy-related cost and surveillance interval agreement (colorectal cancer risk category). Estimates were calculated based on national reimbursement rates and guidelines in four countries. We analyzed 1134 patients (59 % men, median age 67 years) with 1716 polyps. Compared with total removal, the endoscopist-alone and CADx-assisted leave-in-situ strategies reduced the removed polyps per patient from 1.51 (95 %CI 1.48-1.54) to 1.18 (95 %CI 1.16-1.20) and 1.12 (95 %CI 1.00-1.14), respectively; however, 0.023 (95 %CI 0.015-0.033) and 0.021 (95 %CI 0.014-0.031) neoplasms per patient were left in situ, respectively. The mean colonoscopy cost decreased by $44 (endoscopist alone) and $46 (CADx assistance) in the USA, $22 and $19 in the UK, $21 and $19 in Japan, and $32 and $30 in Norway, respectively. Surveillance interval agreement decreased to 99.2 % (endoscopist alone) and 99.0 % (CADx assistance) in the USA, 99.8 % and 99.8 % in the UK, 97.9 % and 97.1 % in Japan, and 99.9 % and 99.9 % in Norway, respectively. Both endoscopist-alone and CADx-assisted optical diagnosis reduce colonoscopy costs. The risk of missed adenomas and surveillance interval deviations appear marginal.