Accelerated immune ageing is associated with COVID-19 disease severity
Lord JM., Veenith T., Sullivan J., Sharma-Oates A., Richter AG., Greening NJ., McAuley HJC., Evans RA., Moss P., Moore SC., Turtle L., Gautam N., Gilani A., Bajaj M., Wain LV., Brightling C., Raman B., Marks M., Singapuri A., Elneima O., Openshaw PJM., Duggal NA., Abel K., Adamali H., Adeloye D., Adeyemi O., Adrego R., AguilarJimenez LA., Ahmad S., Ahmad Haider N., Ahmed R., Ahwireng N., Ainsworth M., Al-Sheklly B., Alamoudi A., Ali M., Aljaroof M., All AM., Allan L., Allen RJ., Allerton L., Allsop L., Almeida P., Altmann D., Alvarez Corral M., Amoils S., Anderson D., Antoniades C., Arbane G., Arias A., Armour C., Armstrong L., Armstrong N., Arnold D., Arnold H., Ashish A., Ashworth A., Ashworth M., Aslani S., Assefa-Kebede H., Atkin C., Atkin P., Aul R., Aung H., Austin L., Avram C., Ayoub A., Babores M., Baggott R., Bagshaw J., Baguley D., Bailey L., Baillie JK., Bain S., Bakali M., Bakau M., Baldry E., Baldwin D., Baldwin M., Ballard C., Banerjee A., Bang B., Barker RE., Barman L., Barratt S., Barrett F., Basire D., Basu N., Bates M., Bates A., Batterham R., Baxendale H., Bayes H., Beadsworth M., Beckett P., Beggs M., Begum M., Beirne P., Bell D., Bell R., Bennett K., Beranova E., Bermperi A., Berridge A., Berry C., Betts S., Bevan E., Bhui K., Bingham M., Birchall K., Bishop L., Bisnauthsing K., Blaikely J., Bloss A., Bolger A., Bolton CE., Bonnington J., Botkai A., Bourne C., Bourne M., Bramham K., Brear L., Breen G., Breeze J., Briggs A., Bright E., Brill S., Brindle K., Broad L., Broadley A., Brookes C., Broome M., Brown A., Brown A., Brown J., Brown J., Brown JS., Brown M., Brown M., Brown V., Brugha T., Brunskill N., Buch M., Buckley P., Bularga A., Bullmore E., Burden L., Burdett T., Burn D., Burns G., Burns A., Busby J., Butcher R., Butt A., Byrne S., Cairns P., Calder PC., Calvelo E., Carborn H., Card B., Carr C., Carr L., Carson G., Carter P., Casey A., Cassar M., Cavanagh J., Chablani M., Chalder T., Chalmers JD., CHambers RC., Chan F., Channon KM., Chapman K., Charalambou A., Chaudhuri N., Checkley A., Chen J., Cheng Y., Chetham L., Childs C., Chilvers ER., Chinoy H., Chiribiri A., Chong-James K., Choudhury G., Choudhury N., Chowienczyk P., Christie C., Chrystal M., Clark D., Clark C., Clarke J., Clohisey S., Coakley G., Coburn Z., Coetzee S., Cole J., Coleman C., Conneh F., Connell D., Connolly B., Connor L., Cook A., Cooper B., Cooper J., Cooper S., Copeland D., Cosier T., Coulding M., Coupland C., Cox E., Craig T., Crisp P., Cristiano D., Crooks MG., Cross A., Cruz I., Cullinan P., Cuthbertson D., Daines L., Dalton M., Daly P., Daniels A., Dark P., Dasgin J., David A., David C., Davies E., Davies F., Davies G., Davies GA., Davies K., Davies MJ., Dawson J., Daynes E., De Soyza A., Deakin B., Deans A., Deas C., Deery J., Defres S., Dell A., Dempsey K., Denneny E., Dennis J., Dewar A., Dharmagunawardena R., Diar-Bakerly N., Dickens C., Dipper A., Diver S., Diwanji SN., Dixon M., Djukanovic R., Dobson H., Dobson SL., Docherty AB., Donaldson A., Dong T., Dormand N., Dougherty A., Dowling R., Drain S., Draxlbauer K., Drury K., Dulawan P., Dunleavy A., Dunn S., Dupont C., Earley J., Easom N., Echevarria C., Edwards S., Edwardson C., El-Taweel H., Elliott A., Elliott K., Ellis Y., Elmer A., Evans D., Evans H., Evans J., Evans R., Evans RI., Evans T., Evenden C., Evison L., Fabbri L., Fairbairn S., Fairman A., Fallon K., Faluyi D., Favager C., Fayzan T., Featherstone J., Felton T., Finch J., Finney S., Finnigan J., Finnigan L., Fisher H., Fletcher S., Flockton R., Flynn M., Foot H., Foote D., Ford A., Forton D., Fraile E., Francis C., Francis R., Francis S., Frankel A., Fraser E., Free R., French N., Fu X., Fuld J., Furniss J., Garner L., Geddes JR., George J., George P., Gibbons M., Gill M., Gilmour L., Gleeson F., Glossop J., Glover S., Goodman N., Goodwin C., Gooptu B., Gordon H., Gorsuch T., Greatorex M., Greenhaff PL., Greenhalf W., Greenhalgh A., Greenwood J., Gregory H., Gregory R., Grieve D., Griffin D., Griffiths L., Guerdette A-M., Guillen Guio B., Gummadi M., Gupta A., Gurram S., Guthrie E., Guy Z., Henson H., Hadley K., Haggar A., Hainey K., Hairsine B., Haldar P., Hall I., Hall L., Halling-Brown M., Hamil R., Hancock A., Hancock K., Hanley NA., Haq S., Hardwick HE., Hardy E., Hardy T., Hargadon B., Harrington K., Harris E., Harris VC., Harrison EM., Harrison P., Hart N., Harvey A., Harvey M., Harvie M., Haslam L., Havinden-Williams M., Hawkes J., Hawkings N., Haworth J., Hayday A., Haynes M., Hazeldine J., Hazelton T., Heaney LG., Heeley C., Heeney JL., Heightman M., Heller S., Henderson M., Hesselden L., Hewitt M., Highett V., Hillman T., Hiwot T., Ho LP., Hoare A., Hoare M., Hockridge J., Hogarth P., Holbourn A., Holden S., Holdsworth L., Holgate D., Holland M., Holloway L., Holmes K., Holmes M., Holroyd-Hind B., Holt L., Hormis A., Horsley A., Hosseini A., Hotopf M., Houchen-Wolloff L., Howard K., Howard LS., Howell A., Hufton E., Hughes AD., Hughes J., Hughes R., Humphries A., Huneke N., Hurditch E., Hurst J., Husain M., Hussell T., Hutchinson J., Ibrahim W., Ilyas F., Ingham J., Ingram L., Ionita D., Isaacs K., Ismail K., Jackson T., Jacob J., James WY., Jang W., Jarman C., Jarrold I., Jarvis H., Jastrub R., Jayaraman B., Jenkins RG., Jezzard P., Jiwa K., Johnson C., Johnson S., Johnston D., Jolley CJ., Jones D., Jones G., Jones H., Jones H., Jones I., Jones L., Jones MG., Jones S., Jose S., Kabir T., Kaltsakas G., Kamwa V., Kanellakis N., Kaprowska S., Kausar Z., Keenan N., Kelly S., Kemp G., Kerr S., Kerslake H., Key AL., Khan F., Khunti K., Kilroy S., King B., King C., Kingham L., Kirk J., Kitterick P., Klenerman P., Knibbs L., Knight S., Knighton A., Kon O., Kon S., Kon SS., Koprowska S., Korszun A., Koychev I., Kurasz C., Kurupati P., Laing C., Lamlum H., Landers G., Langenberg C., Lasserson D., Lavelle-Langham L., Lawrie A., Lawson C., Lawson C., Layton A., Lea A., Leavy OC., Lee D., Lee J-H., Lee E., Leitch K., Lenagh R., Lewis D., Lewis J., Lewis KE., Lewis V., Lewis-Burke N., Li X., Light T., Lightstone L., Lilaonitkul W., Lim L., Linford S., Lingford-Hughes A., Lipman M., Liyanage K., Lloyd A., Logan S., Lomas D., Lone NI., Loosley R., Lota H., Lovegrove W., Lucey A., Lukaschuk E., Lye A., Lynch C., MacDonald S., MacGowan G., Macharia I., Mackie J., Macliver L., Madathil S., Madzamba G., Magee N., Magtoto MM., Mairs N., Majeed N., Major E., Malein F., Malim M., Mallison G., Man WD-C., Mandal S., Mangion K., Manisty C., Manley R., March K., Marciniak S., Marino P., Mariveles M., Marouzet E., Marsh S., Marshall B., Marshall M., Martin J., Martineau A., Martinez LM., Maskell N., Matila D., Matimba-Mupaya W., Matthews L., Mbuyisa A., McAdoo S., McAllister-Williams H., McArdle A., McArdle P., McAulay D., McCann GP., McCormick J., McCormick W., McCourt P., Mcgarvey L., McGhee C., Mcgee K., McGinness J., McGlynn K., McGovern A., McGuinness H., McInnes IB., McIntosh J., McIvor E., McIvor K., McLeavey L., McMahon A., McMahon MJ., McMorrow L., Mcnally T., McNarry M., McNeill J., McQueen A., McShane H., Mears C., Megson C., Megson S., Mehta P., Meiring J., Melling L., Mencias M., Menzies D., Merida Morillas M., Michael A., Miller C., Milligan L., Mills C., Mills G., Mills NL., Milner L., Misra S., Mitchell J., Mohamed A., Mohamed N., Mohammed S., Molyneaux PL., Monteiro W., Moriera S., Morley A., Morrison L., Morriss R., Morrow A., Moss AJ., Motohashi K., Msimanga N., Mukaetova-Ladinska E., Munawar U., Murira J., Nanda U., Nassa H., Nasseri M., Neal A., Needham R., Neill P., Neubauer S., Newby DE., Newell H., Newman T., Newman J., Newton-Cox A., Nicholson T., Nicoll D., Nikolaidis A., Nolan CM., Noonan MJ., Norman C., Novotny P., Nunag J., Nwafor L., Nwanguma U., Nyaboko J., O’Brien C., O’Donnell K., O’Regan D., O’Brien L., Odell N., Ogg G., Olaosebikan O., Oliver C., Omar Z., Orriss-Dib L., Osborne L., Osbourne R., Ostermann M., Overton C., Owen J., Oxton J., Pack J., Pacpaco E., Paddick S., Painter S., Pakzad A., Palmer S., Papineni P., Paques K., Paradowski K., Pareek M., Parekh D., Parfrey H., Pariante C., Parker S., Parmar J., Patale S., Patel B., Patel M., Patel S., Pattenadk D., Pavlides M., Payne S., Pearce L., Pearl JE., Peckham D., Pendlebury J., Peng Y., Pennington C., Peralta I., Perkins E., Peterkin Z., Peto T., Petousi N., Petrie J., Pfeffer P., Phipps J., Pimm J., Piper Hanley K., Pius R., Plant H., Plein S., Plekhanova T., Plowright M., Poinasamy K., Polgar O., Poll L., Porter JC., Porter J., Portukhay S., Powell N., Prabhu A., Pratt J., Price A., Price C., Price C., Price D., Price L., Price L., Prickett A., Propescu J., Prosper S., Pugmire S., Quaid S., Quigley J., Quint J., Qureshi H., Qureshi IN., Radhakrishnan K., Rahman NM., Ralser M., Ramos A., Ramos H., Rangeley J., Rangelov B., Ratcliffe L., Ravencroft P., Reddington A., Reddy R., Reddy A., Redfearn H., Redwood D., Reed A., Rees M., Rees T., Regan K., Reynolds W., Ribeiro C., Richards A., Richardson E., Richardson M., Rivera-Ortega P., Roberts K., Robertson E., Robinson E., Robinson L., Roche L., Roddis C., Rodger J., Ross A., Ross G., Rossdale J., Rostron A., Rowe A., Rowland A., Rowland J., Rowland MJ., Rowland-Jones SL., Roy K., Roy M., Rudan I., Russell R., Russell E., Saalmink G., Sabit R., Sage EK., Samakomva T., Samani N., Sampson C., Samuel K., Samuel R., Sanderson A., Sapey E., Saralaya D., Sargent J., Sarginson C., Sass T., Sattar N., Saunders K., Saunders RM., Saunders P., Saunders LC., Savill H., Saxon W., Sayer A., Schronce J., Schwaeble W., Scott JT., Scott K., Selby N., Semple MG., Sereno M., Sewell TA., Shah A., Shah K., Shah P., Shankar-Hari M., Sharma M., Sharpe C., Sharpe M., Shashaa S., Shaw A., Shaw K., Shaw V., Sheikh A., Shelton S., Shenton L., Shevket K., Shikotra A., Short J., Siddique S., Siddiqui S., Sidebottom J., Sigfrid L., Simons G., Simpson J., Simpson N., Singh C., Singh S., Singh SJ., Sissons D., Skeemer J., Slack K., Smith A., Smith D., Smith S., Smith J., Smith L., Soares M., Solano TS., Solly R., Solstice AR., Soulsby T., Southern D., Sowter D., Spears M., Spencer LG., Speranza F., Stadon L., Stanel S., Steele N., Steiner M., Stensel D., Stephens G., Stephenson L., Stern M., Stewart I., Stimpson R., Stockdale S., Stockley J., Stoker W., Stone R., Storrar W., Storrie A., Storton K., Stringer E., Strong-Sheldrake S., Stroud N., Subbe C., Sudlow CL., Suleiman Z., Summers C., Summersgill C., Sutherland D., Sykes DL., Sykes R., Talbot N., Tan AL., Tarusan L., Tavoukjian V., Taylor A., Taylor C., Taylor J., Te A., Tedd H., Tee CJ., Teixeira J., Tench H., Terry S., Thackray-Nocera S., Thaivalappil F., Thamu B., Thickett D., Thomas C., Thomas DC., Thomas S., Thomas AK., Thomas-Woods T., Thompson T., Thompson AAR., Thornton T., Thorpe M., Thwaites RS., Tilley J., Tinker N., Tiongson GF., Tobin M., Tomlinson J., Tong C., Toshner M., Touyz R., Tripp KA., Tunnicliffe E., Turnbull A., Turner E., Turner S., Turner V., Turner K., Turney S., Turton H., Ugoji J., Ugwuoke R., Upthegrove R., Valabhji J., Ventura M., Vere J., Vickers C., Vinson B., Wade E., Wade P., Wainwright T., Wajero LO., Walder S., Walker S., Walker S., Wall E., Wallis T., Walmsley S., Walsh JA., Walsh S., Warburton L., Ward TJC., Warwick K., Wassall H., Waterson S., Watson E., Watson L., Watson J., Weir McCall J., Welch C., Welch H., Welsh B., Wessely S., West S., Weston H., Wheeler H., White S., Whitehead V., Whitney J., Whittaker S., Whittam B., Whitworth V., Wight A., Wild J., Wilkins M., Wilkinson D., Williams B., Williams N., Williams N., Williams J., Williams-Howard SA., Willicombe M., Willis G., Willoughby J., Wilson A., Wilson D., Wilson I., Window N., Witham M., Wolf-Roberts R., Wood C., Woodhead F., Woods J., Wootton DG., Wormleighton J., Worsley J., Wraith D., Wrey Brown C., Wright C., Wright L., Wright S., Wyles J., Wynter I., Xu M., Yasmin N., Yasmin S., Yates T., Yip KP., Young B., Young S., Young A., Yousuf AJ., Zawia A., Zeidan L., Zhao B., Zheng B., Zongo O.
Abstract Background The striking increase in COVID-19 severity in older adults provides a clear example of immunesenescence, the age-related remodelling of the immune system. To better characterise the association between convalescent immunesenescence and acute disease severity, we determined the immune phenotype of COVID-19 survivors and non-infected controls. Results We performed detailed immune phenotyping of peripheral blood mononuclear cells isolated from 103 COVID-19 survivors 3–5 months post recovery who were classified as having had severe (n = 56; age 53.12 ± 11.30 years), moderate (n = 32; age 52.28 ± 11.43 years) or mild (n = 15; age 49.67 ± 7.30 years) disease and compared with age and sex-matched healthy adults (n = 59; age 50.49 ± 10.68 years). We assessed a broad range of immune cell phenotypes to generate a composite score, IMM-AGE, to determine the degree of immune senescence. We found increased immunesenescence features in severe COVID-19 survivors compared to controls including: a reduced frequency and number of naïve CD4 and CD8 T cells (p < 0.0001); increased frequency of EMRA CD4 (p < 0.003) and CD8 T cells (p < 0.001); a higher frequency (p < 0.0001) and absolute numbers (p < 0.001) of CD28−ve CD57+ve senescent CD4 and CD8 T cells; higher frequency (p < 0.003) and absolute numbers (p < 0.02) of PD-1 expressing exhausted CD8 T cells; a two-fold increase in Th17 polarisation (p < 0.0001); higher frequency of memory B cells (p < 0.001) and increased frequency (p < 0.0001) and numbers (p < 0.001) of CD57+ve senescent NK cells. As a result, the IMM-AGE score was significantly higher in severe COVID-19 survivors than in controls (p < 0.001). Few differences were seen for those with moderate disease and none for mild disease. Regression analysis revealed the only pre-existing variable influencing the IMM-AGE score was South Asian ethnicity ($$\beta$$ β = 0.174, p = 0.043), with a major influence being disease severity ($$\beta$$ β = 0.188, p = 0.01). Conclusions Our analyses reveal a state of enhanced immune ageing in survivors of severe COVID-19 and suggest this could be related to SARS-Cov-2 infection. Our data support the rationale for trials of anti-immune ageing interventions for improving clinical outcomes in these patients with severe disease.