Blood eosinophil count and airway epithelial transcriptome relationships in COPD versus asthma.
George L., Taylor AR., Esteve-Codina A., Soler Artigas M., Thun GA., Bates S., Pavlidis S., Wagers S., Boland A., Prasse A., Boschetto P., Parr DG., Nowinski A., Barta I., Hohlfeld J., Greulich T., van den Berge M., Hiemstra PS., Timens W., Hinks T., Wenzel S., Siddiqui S., Richardson M., Venge P., Heath S., Gut I., Tobin MD., Edwards L., Riley JH., Djukanovic R., Auffray C., De-Meulder B., Erik-Dahlen S., Adcock IM., Chung KF., Ziegler-Heitbrock L., Sterk PJ., Singh D., Brightling CE., U-BIOPRED and the EvA study teams .
BackgroundWhether the clinical or pathophysiologic significance of the "treatable trait" high blood eosinophil count in COPD is the same as for asthma remains controversial. We sought to determine the relationship between the blood eosinophil count, clinical characteristics and gene expression from bronchial brushings in COPD and asthma.MethodsSubjects were recruited into a COPD (emphysema versus airway disease [EvA]) or asthma cohort (Unbiased BIOmarkers in PREDiction of respiratory disease outcomes, U-BIOPRED). We determined gene expression using RNAseq in EvA (n = 283) and Affymetrix microarrays in U-BIOPRED (n = 85). We ran linear regression analysis of the bronchial brushings transcriptional signal versus blood eosinophil counts as well as differential expression using a blood eosinophil > 200 cells/μL as a cut-off. The false discovery rate was controlled at 1% (with continuous values) and 5% (with dichotomized values).ResultsThere were no differences in age, gender, lung function, exercise capacity and quantitative computed tomography between eosinophilic versus noneosinophilic COPD cases. Total serum IgE was increased in eosinophilic asthma and COPD. In EvA, there were 12 genes with a statistically significant positive association with the linear blood eosinophil count, whereas in U-BIOPRED, 1197 genes showed significant associations (266 positive and 931 negative). The transcriptome showed little overlap between genes and pathways associated with blood eosinophil counts in asthma versus COPD. Only CST1 was common to eosinophilic asthma and COPD and was replicated in independent cohorts.ConclusionDespite shared "treatable traits" between asthma and COPD, the molecular mechanisms underlying these clinical entities are predominately different.